Online Store
RBS 6 Nations Apps
RBS 6 Nations Video
RBS RugbyForce
No ALT tag specified

RBS 6 Nations match video highlights

Watch the latest Video highlights
Official Championship App

The Official Championship App

Keep on top of all the action through the official app. Includes video, news, history, stats and more...
No ALT tag specified

RBS 6 Nations Live Challenge App 2013

Click here to learn more!
No ALT tag specified

Official Online Store

RBS 6 Nations full kit range now available online
Official Magazine 2013

Official Magazine 2013

Click here to Download
No ALT tag specified
Scotland to learn from Hines experience
13 January 2007, 11:40 am
The Scottish Rugby Union have vowed to tighten up their knowledge of international disciplinary procedures after the confusion which surrounded the late withdrawal of Nathan Hines from the autumn Test against Australia.
The Perpignan lock was cited by Stade Francais after allegedly kicking Canadian back-row forward Mike James in the face during a game on November 4.

A French disciplinary panel ruled that the 30-year-old was guilty of foul play and suspended him for 20 days until December 11.

But the Scots picked Hines for the visit of the Wallabies after an appeal against the ban was lodged.

The SRU had offered to send legal representation to the hearing but Perpignan told them it was a pre-hearing and neither the player nor a lawyer would be required to attend.

However, Hines was stood down late on the eve of the 44-15 defeat after talks between the SRU, the International Rugby Board and the Ligue Nationale de Rugby.

An SRU internal inquiry has now found gaps in knowledge about the complex disciplinary processes in other countries.

SRU chief executive Gordon McKie said: Whilst I feel we made the right decision in standing down Nathan Hines from the Australia game, it came very late.

I propose to strengthen our internal processes to ensure there is no repeat of this sort of situation in the future.

Admittedly this was a particularly complex case but nevertheless there will be much better communication between the Scotland management team and administrative, legal and disciplinary advisers, moving forward.

We must ensure a highly complex area such as discipline is fully understood, especially when it involves our overseas international players.

There is no doubt these are complex areas where genuine errors can occur.

However, our internal processes will be refined in the light of this episode and we will ensure that there is much greater consultation with the IRB over their interpretation of such regulations.

Hines said: I was told by my club that there was to be a preliminary hearing to determine whether I needed to appear before a discipline panel, then learned I had been banned.

Thats where the confusion arose as I always denied the complaint and protested my innocence.


RBS Six Nations Store

 
ADD TO DEL.ICIO.USDel.icio.usShare this page
ADD TO DIGGDiggShare this page
ADD TO FACEBOOKFacebookShare this page
ADD TO GOOGLEGoogleShare this page
ADD TO NEWSVINENewsvineShare this page
ADD TO REDDITRedditShare this page
ADD TO STUMBLEUPONStumbleUponShare this page
ADD TO YAHOO MYWEBYahooShare this page
ADD TO TWITTERTwitterShare this page
Previews & Reports
England Latest
France Latest
Ireland Latest
Italy Latest
Scotland Latest
Wales Latest
Team Statistics onlyinclude Five & Six Nations games from 1992 to the present day
Player Statistics onlyinclude Five & Six Nations appearances since 1992
© 2013 delivered by Sotic powered by OpenText WSM